Main Menu
Related Practices

No Evidence, No Deposition

The Zelle Lonestar Lowdown
September 30, 2026

by Anna Kuhlman

In a significant procedural victory for insurance carriers, a Corpus Christi-Edinburg Court of Appeals conditionally granted mandamus relief in favor of the insurer, in In Re Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Company, Allstate Texas Lloyds, Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company, and James Rudish, No. 13-26-00576-CV, 2026 WL 2529130, at *1 (Tex. App. Aug. 26, 2026). In the matter, the court of appeals held that the parties seeking presuit depositions under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 202 had failed to present any evidence in support of obtaining such discovery and further found that the trial court must vacate its previous order authorizing the depositions. Id. at *4.

Background

The dispute arose when a group of insureds claimed they were victims of vandalism stemming from the sale and installation of solar panels. Id. at *1. The insureds submitted claims to their insurers on the grounds that the installation of inoperable solar panels constituted covered vandalism; however, their insurers denied coverage after finding there was no evidence of vandalism. Id.

Subsequently, the insureds filed a petition seeking presuit depositions of Allstate's corporate representatives and claim representatives, as provided under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 202. Id. The insureds alleged generally that the depositions were for use in an anticipated suit and to investigate potential claims or suits. Id.

The trial court granted the petition and explained that "[a]llowing the requested depositions may prevent a failure or delay of justice in anticipated litigation," and that "the likely benefit of permitting the requested presuit discovery to investigate the potential claims and anticipated litigation outweighs the burden or expense of the procedure." Id.

Allstate sought mandamus relief and put forth two arguments: "(1) the trial court abused its discretion by granting the Rule 202 petition, and (2) they lack an adequate remedy by appeal to cure this error." Id. at *2.

Analysis

The court of appeals agreed with Allstate, emphasizing that the insureds presented no evidence to support their request for presuit depositions. Id. at *3. The court explained that “a petitioner seeking a presuit deposition must present evidence to meet its burden to establish the facts necessary to obtain the deposition.” Id. (internal citations omitted). Sworn or verified pleadings, counsel’s arguments, and documents not admitted into evidence do not satisfy this evidentiary burden. Id. Moreover, “the required findings cannot be implied in support of the trial court’s order.” Id. Accordingly, when a petitioner fails to present the required evidence, a trial court abuses its discretion by ordering a Rule 202 deposition. Id.

When finding the trial court in this case abused its discretion, the court of appeals stated:

Under the applicable law as discussed above: (1) the [insured] parties' petition, even if verified, does not constitute competent evidence to prove the facts asserted therein; (2) the real parties did not offer their petition or its exhibits into evidence, and documents not admitted into evidence cannot be considered as proof; (3) the trial court could not take judicial notice of the real parties' allegations in their petition; and (4) the arguments of real parties' counsel are not evidence.

The court of appeals further held that mandamus relief was proper given that Allstate lacked an adequate remedy through ordinary appeal. Id. at *4. The Court of Appeals explained that “if discovery takes place under an improper order, the error cannot be rectified,” and specifically, that “[o]nce the deposition has been taken, it cannot be untaken.” Id. (internal citations omitted).

The Lowdown: In re Allstate is a favorable decision for insurers because it squarely places the burden under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 202 with the party seeking the presuit depositions. When this evidentiary foundation is missing, the associated discovery order is likely improper and vulnerable to mandamus relief.


The opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm or its clients. This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal advice.

Back to Page