Related Practices
Hail No! Focus on the Pleadings!
The Zelle Lonestar LowdownNovember 2, 2026
Texoma Cowboy Church, Inc. v. Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I., No. 7:26-CV-00062-O, 2026 WL 3166210, at *1 (N.D. Tex. Oct. 22, 2026)
In Texas, even the most simple disputes over the cause and extent of damage can end up in a lawsuit alleging standard breach of contract, Texas Insurance Code violations, and breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing. Those are easy hurdles to jump in a federal court complaint. But when the policyholder alleges fraud, negligent misrepresentation based on the same supporting facts as fraud, and conspiracy, federal courts pay special attention. We call this a “throw everything at the wall and see what sticks” type of pleading.
In Texoma Cowboy Church, Inc. v. Church Mutual Insurance Co., S.I., 2026 WL 3166210 (N.D. Tex. Oct. 22, 2026), Chief Judge Reed O’Connor threw out half of the claims, and he made a useful point for carriers along the way.
The Storm
On April 5, 2025, a hail and windstorm hit Texoma Cowboy Church’s property on U.S. Highway 281 outside Wichita Falls, which was insured by Church Mutual. The church hired a public adjuster and Church Mutual hired an engineering firm. The engineer found that the hail did hit the roof, leaving dents and separating panels. Church Mutual then had a third-party contractor prepare a bid. In December 2025 it issued a replacement-cost estimate and payment after application of the policy deductible and depreciation. But the church didn’t think the payment was enough and filed suit.
The Lawsuit
The church’s state court petition pleaded eight causes of action: breach of contract (both the ordinary kind and the anticipatory kind), bad faith, DTPA violations, Prompt Payment Act violations, unfair insurance practices, negligent misrepresentation, fraud, and conspiracy.
Church Mutual moved to dismiss four of them: fraud, negligent misrepresentation, gross negligence, and conspiracy. The court granted the motion on all four, with prejudice.
An Estimate Isn’t Fraud
The church argued that because the estimate left out costs it believed should have been included, Church Mutual had knowingly defrauded it. The court rejected that. Under the Texas Supreme Court’s decision in Transportation Insurance Co. v. Faircloth, 898 S.W.2d 269 “an expression of opinion about monetary value is not a representation of fact which gives rise to an action for fraud.” An estimate built on an adjuster’s and a contractor’s professional judgment is an opinion about value. Someone can disagree with it and sue over it as a breach of contract, but disagreeing with it doesn’t make it fraud.
Name Names
The fraud allegations were also too vague. The petition said the misconduct was committed by “Defendant individually and/or through its agent(s).” The court held that this phrasing doesn’t satisfy Rule 9(b), which requires a fraud plaintiff to plead who said what, when, where, and how.
The church tried to keep its negligent misrepresentation claim alive by arguing that it rested on different facts and therefore didn’t need the same level of detail. The court disagreed. Both claims came from the same allegations, so both had to meet Rule 9(b), and both failed.
It’s a Contract Case
The court also applied Texas’s independent injury / economic loss rule. When the harm is that the plaintiff didn’t receive money owed under a contract, the claim belongs in contract, not tort. The church’s injury was an underpaid claim, so its tort theories couldn’t proceed.
A Property Insurance Dispute Isn’t an “Extreme Risk”
Gross negligence under Texas law requires an “extreme degree of risk.” Courts have read that to mean risks like death, serious physical injury, or financial ruin. A disputed insurance payment doesn’t meet that standard. The petition also didn’t allege facts showing Church Mutual was actually aware of any such risk, which is the second element. That claim was dismissed too.
Tin Foil Hats
The conspiracy count alleged that Church Mutual was “a member of a combination of two or more persons” who reached a “meeting of the minds” to mislead the church. The petition never said who the other members were or what they did. The court called this a recitation of the elements and dismissed it. The claim also failed for a second reason: a conspiracy claim depends on an underlying tort, and the fraud claim was already gone.
Not a Complete Win
As expected, the breach of contract, bad faith, DTPA, Chapter 541, and Chapter 542 claims are still in the case. The dispute will come down to the usual question: whether certain damages were caused by the storm or preexisted. Prompt-payment interest is still a live risk if any additional amount turns out to be owed.
Takeaways
- Pay attention to the pleadings (or ensure your attorneys do) and file the partial motion to dismiss. Fraud, conspiracy, and gross negligence claims show up from time to time, and Rule 12(b)(6) is an effective way to remove them early.
- Cite Faircloth in every “the estimate was fraud” case. This opinion is a clean, recent federal application of it.
- Document the basis for the estimate. The court treated this estimate as an opinion partly because it rested on outside professional judgment from an engineer and a third-party contractor. A file showing that basis puts the carrier in a better position.
The opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm or its clients. This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal advice.